Choosing payroll software is one of the most important infrastructure decisions a small business can make. For business leaders, it’s critical to know which features, capabilities, and support systems to look for as you evaluate your options.
In this article we discuss:
Payroll is a core function for every business, yet few feel they have the right tools to execute it effectively. Workday research found that while 92% of business leaders acknowledge payroll’s strategic importance, 89% also feel that their current solutions need to do more.
For small businesses, capability gaps in payroll can have significant implications. Even a minor mistake can lead to compliance issues or costly delays that set the business back. That’s why payroll software is one of the most critical small business technology tools in your tech stack.
The best payroll software saves time, reduces risk, and scales with your company as it grows. Knowing how to choose the right payroll solution for your needs is an important first step for small business owners.
While 92% of business leaders know payroll is important, 89% feel their current solutions need to do more.
Most small businesses already operate with limited time, staff, and margin for error. Processing payroll manually can further drain resources and leave room for mistakes that impact compliance, tax obligations, and employee satisfaction.
Small business payroll software streamlines these tasks, reduces the risk of tax penalties, and keeps operations running smoothly. For businesses trying to grow, that consistency is essential. When payroll systems are designed to meet the unique needs of small businesses, the benefits are immediate and include:
Time savings through business process automation
Fewer payroll errors and reduced time spent on corrections
On-time tax filings that lower the risk of penalties
Improved employee experience with access to pay and tax info
A scalable system that grows with your business
Deployed correctly, payroll software becomes an invisible engine that runs in the background so small business owners can stay focused on what matters most—innovation, strategy, and growth.
When you know what features to look for, your payroll software can align with your business needs and adapt to your unique workflows. Here are key features to look for as you evaluate your options for payroll services.
Routine tasks like calculating wages and issuing payments take up valuable time. Payroll automation handles these behind the scenes, running scheduled pay cycles, calculating payroll deductions, and generating tax forms with minimal oversight. It cuts down on human error, ensuring you pay employees on time and letting your finance team focus on higher-value work.
Regulations change constantly, especially around state and federal payroll taxes. Software with built-in compliance tools keeps your business in line with current requirements, reducing the risk of missed deadlines or costly fines.
Payroll software should be user-friendly for teams running payroll and the employees receiving it. Look for platforms with intuitive dashboards and clean workflows that reduce the learning curve for your team. On the employee side, look for self-service features that grant access to pay stubs, tax forms, and direct deposit settings to help cut down on administrative requests and allow individuals to manage their own information.
Payroll doesn’t exist in a vacuum, which is why software integrations matter. Strong platforms integrate seamlessly with other key tools, like accounting, time tracking, and HR systems. This creates a single source of truth and cuts down on manual data entry, saves teams time, and ensures payroll accuracy.
Even great software requires support. Prioritize vendors that offer responsive and knowledgeable support teams, especially if payroll isn’t your area of expertise. Whether it’s chat, phone, or onboarding help, reliable support can make or break your experience and the value you gain from your tool.
Payroll data includes sensitive employee information. Choose a provider with strong security protocols, encryption, and privacy safeguards. Make sure that they comply with regulations like GDPR or CCPA if applicable to your business.
Modern payroll software increasingly includes AI to help small businesses make smarter decisions. AI can do things like identify anomalies in payroll runs, flag potential compliance risks, or provide predictive insights about labor costs. For lean teams, this kind of built-in intelligence acts like a virtual strategic advisor. AI agents can even handle entire end-to-end payroll workflows with minimal oversight from human employees.
With so many options on the market, it's important to know what to prioritize when evaluating your top potential vendors. A feature checklist is helpful, but it’s just the start. Understanding how those features translate to your daily operations, team structure, and long-term goals is what enables smarter decision-making. Here are the top seven considerations small business leades should keep in mind.
A clear pricing structure helps avoid surprises down the line. Look for vendors that clearly communicate monthly fees, user tiers, and add-on costs. Watch out for rigid long-term contracts or hidden fees. Contract flexibility is key, especially if you are just starting out.
Key features to look for in your small business payroll software: automation, ease of use, data security, and AI capabilities.
Online reviews and user feedback offer insights beyond a specific solution’s marketing site. Focus on comments from businesses similar to yours to get a realistic sense of strengths and weaknesses. Look for consistent praise—or consistent complaints—about support, usability, and reliability.
The best payroll software both meets your current needs and is designed to grow with you. Some platforms are tailored for very small teams, while others support complex org structures. Consider your projected growth and make sure the tool won’t limit you later.
Responsive support is critical when something goes wrong with payroll. Look for vendors that offer support through channels that work for your teams (e.g. live chat, email, mobile app, phone, etc.) and offer dedicated onboarding to set you up for success. Bonus points if they offer help during payroll run times, not just business hours.
A trial or demo is a smart, low-risk way to explore whether a platform fits your workflows. They help you test real workflows, identify deal-breakers, and confirm the platform is intuitive for your team. You can also use your trial period to ask questions and evaluate vendor responsiveness.
Your payroll needs may change as you expand to new regions, hire remote employees, or take on contingent workers. Look for flexible online payroll software that will allow you to adjust rules, permissions, and workflows without rebuilding from scratch. Cloud-based platforms are often better equipped to scale quickly and roll out updates without requiring costly IT support or downtime.
Some industries have unique payroll requirements such as prevailing wage rules, union reporting, or shift differentials. If your business falls into one of these categories, make sure your software can handle your specific tax codes, labor laws, and compliance obligations.
Key considerations when choosing your payroll solution include contract terms, scalability, customer support, and industry-specific capabilities.
No payroll solution is perfect for everyone, but the right one will feel seamless for your business. As you narrow your options, think about how each platform fits into your existing payroll processes: Does it adapt to your systems or force you to change how you work? Can it keep pace with your hiring strategy, regulatory requirements, and reporting needs?
Prioritize a solution that supports where you are now and where you're heading. The right fit won’t just process standard payroll tasks; it will give you the foundation to make payroll a seamless and strategic part of HR as your business continues to grow.
Is your business ready to transform its approach to HR and payroll? Download the Workday HCM and Payroll Buyer's Guide to refine your solution selection criteria and build a compelling business case for change.
More Reading
Learn how a powerful scenario model’s carefully selected components can translate a future story into usable data.
Vendors have a direct impact on daily business performance and risk exposure. Managing those relationships with discipline and structure strengthens performance and creates a more resilient third-party network.
Every business faces risks and uncertainty. With a structured risk assessment framework in place, your teams can navigate change and disruption with speed and resilience.